logoalt Hacker News

waterTanuki • yesterday at 11:50 PM • 9 replies • view on HN

SpaceX has received more than $22B in subsidies from taxpayer money. They were built off of public funding as much as NASA was. At this point, they are not entitled to keep rocket designs and experiment results secret (except where national security is a concern) from other U.S. competitors. Any company that can obtain a security clearance and demonstrate ability to build should be able to receive these designs from the Federal Government. It's extremely inefficient to keep destroying rockets all so one man can keep his circular financing scheme going.

Armchair scientists who come along and say "Look what they did that NASA couldn't do" don't understand A) SpaceX wouldn't exist at all if not for 6 decades of innovations from NASA & JPL and B) NASA ACTUALLY does space exploration unlike SpaceX, and their budget has to support rovers on other planets, launches, the ISS, astronaut training, weather and climate research (which SpaceX and Blue Origin also benefit from).


Replies

andrewla • today at 12:39 AM

By "received more than $22B in subsidies from taxpayer money" do you mean "the government has spend more than $22B on services from SpaceX" or do you mean "the government has given money to SpaceX for which it receives no specific benefit"?

The Washington Post reporting on this is specifically about government contracts, that is, SpaceX is being paid to provide a service to the government. I don't think I would consider this a subsidy under any reasonable definition.

They have gotten actual subsidies for rural broadband and arguably the incentive tax breaks they've gotten are subsidies; this combines to about $2B or so of true subsidies.

➕ show 1 reply
jryle70 • yesterday at 11:56 PM

Can you provide an example of subsidy for SpaceX? Who else got taxpayer money for space flights according to you?

➕ show 2 replies
bryanlarsen • today at 12:46 AM

The article is about Lockheed/Boeing/ULA, who received far more in subsidies than SpaceX ever did. For example, back when ULA had a launch monopoly, they received $1B a year for "launch readiness". IOW, money for nothing.

lukeify • yesterday at 11:53 PM

Your comment won't appeal to the capitalism-oriented audience of HN but you're right; so right in fact I believe a lot of this is already done.

Usually there is sharing between NASA and all private launch companies when it comes to failures, because they have a vested interest in the outcome of the rockets due to flying payloads on them (someone name me a US rocket that NASA _hasn't_ flown a payload on).

I don't disagree that I think the information sharing could be amped up little, though.

grosswait • today at 1:58 AM

You sound like the subject of Paul Graham's response. https://x.com/paulg/status/2122033524857589799?a=gCWeSGmkpXf...

WorkingDead • yesterday at 11:54 PM

And Boeing-Lockheed hasnt recievend subsidies?

➕ show 1 reply
IAmNotACellist • today at 12:48 AM

"Armchair scientists who come along and say..."

So, yourself?

chipsa • today at 12:28 AM

Contracts for services rendered are subsidies. I see.

➕ show 1 reply