logoalt Hacker News

not_kurt_godel • today at 12:28 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

> The difference is the text consumption. Can you easily retrieve any text you're seeing on the screen into your editor?

> Inserting any piece of text I see on the screen into my notes? A couple of keystrokes. I can grab text in any form, even if it's a frame in a YT video - I'd just select the area, snapshot it - Emacs OCRs the text out of it, which takes milliseconds.

Yes, Mac does this natively/automatically with screenshots. I'd be surprised if I've ever used/needed OCR more than a half-dozen times. Far more often it just gets minorly in the way when I want to copy-paste the image itself.

> I have complete and utter control over text - I can send a query to an LLM in the middle of typing this very comment, without ever missing a beat. I can ask for anything - fact-check it, spell check it, reword it, explain it, give me different variations of the same sentence.

Mac natively offers AI writing tools context menu options in every app for text selections. Right click -> search effectively does the same thing (every search engine has AI functionality featured prominently by default). I believe most browsers also offer straight-to-AI equivalents as well.

> Similarly, I can directly grab a piece of any text in Emacs and send it over to another app, e.g., as a command to run in the terminal.

I can do this natively and trivially on my Mac in every single app without having to learn a bizarre alternate universe of awkward, inconvenient hotkeys.

> What if I could change the 'Open File' dialog in Sublime so I can browse GitHub repos directly instead of folders and files?"

My IDE has featured this prominently as a native option for approximately forever.

> What Emacs grants as a Lisp-REPL loop with a built-in text editor is lowering that affordability bar to the lowest imaginable minimum.

It's literally not affordable to spend my time inefficiently re-inventing the wheel on every common UI/UX task in a usually fundamentally limited and broken way. I need an IDE where it's not a major source of controversy as to whether it's possible to configure basic auto-complete.

> Emacs can search through my browser history too - https://github.com/agzam/browser-hist.el

Having to install a random third-party extension to use a basic browser feature is a bug, not a feature.

...I'm not sure what I'm trying to accomplish by poking these holes. By all means, enjoy using emacs. It's just...strange to me that an emacs user would believe these are selling points when in fact having to configure them myself is a major downgrade from just using the native features in commonly used software.


Replies

iLemming • today at 1:37 AM

I'm attempting to describe to you the joy of skiing, and you're responding with "I don't get the point of dragging my ass all the way to the top of the mountain just to slide down on a piece of wood..."

You will never see the appeal until you give it a heartfelt try yourself; there's too much tacit knowledge that is not easily describable in a few short paragraphs.

You're making it sound as if all the things you're talking about are unknown to me. I wasn't born into Emacs, and I didn't find it in my college years and just decided never to leave. I've been staring at computer screens for decades and have been using Emacs for only a fraction of that time. The only difference between you and me is that I have now seen both sides, I'm intimately familiar with your worldview, and I know the reasons why that side sucks. I'm not saying the Emacs-side is perfect and that there are zero tradeoffs to consider, no.

Lisp and Lisp-based systems have been an impossible sell for a long time, and mostly for emotional rather than practical reasons. "Emacs user" sounds like a lifestyle, and some people outright avoid it just so they don't have to join the tribe.

Those who genuinely try to evaluate the practical side out of curiosity pick some random features or one demo and typically remain unconvinced. I have never heard anyone say "I watched this video/read an article and I decided to try Emacs", because the value of Emacs does not live in any single feature. It lives in how the features compose, and composition is invisible in a demo.

Even using Emacs for a few weeks may not help; the value builds up over time. Each piece on its own looks, sounds and feels unimpressive. Nobody is ever persuaded by a sum they have to imagine. There's no frame that I can use for you to even listen to me; you don't have one. It's very much aligned with Graham's Blub paradox - from inside a less flexible tool, a more flexible one looks like the same thing with weird extras. You only see the difference by looking back from the more flexible side. Most people have never experienced an environment they could change while it runs, so they have nothing to compare it to. My enthusiasm reads to you as sunk-cost bias, even though it clearly isn't. I would happily switch away from Emacs whenever a clearly better alternative comes around. Alas, it just doesn't exist.

> in fact having to configure them myself

Yesterday, I would've said: "Oh sweet summer child, do you really believe you don't configure the 'commonly used software'? You're configuring your own brain and habits to match that software instead..."

But today, that's not even an argument. You can just install Emacs and ask a good model to build you a solution to a problem and then observe and evaluate the workflow differences, easily. Then it opens up a whole world of possibilities where the only limit is your imagination.

"Right-click -> search effectively" is one thing, but when you have a system where you can bind it to a key, to something more complex than a simple right-click, to a foot pedal, to a gesture, to a voice command, to a "Fus Ro Dah" Skyrim call - you just laugh at your own younger, naive self for being so dismissive without even knowing what the hell you were talking about back then.

You're mistakenly thinking I'm offering a replacement for all the tools you already know and use.

> to use a basic browser feature

You didn't even check what it does. It is in fact piggy-backing on the browser feature, it's not replacing it, it is rather enhancing it ten-fold. Emacs doesn't have to replace existing things in your toolbelt. It can act like a glue, like an orchestrator.

➕ show 1 reply