logoalt Hacker News

dijit • today at 12:39 AM • 3 replies • view on HN

Yeah, but the alternative is everyone having a short domain, which is unfortunately difficult due to the fundamental mathematical principle that a low amount of characters has a very small number of options available.

Everything with finite space is expensive, the more finite the more expensive.

So, while I am in favour of what you say, and I’m in favour of self-governance as much as possible, I understand the challenges.


Replies

wmchen • today at 1:42 AM

>Yeah, but the alternative is everyone having a short domain, which is unfortunately difficult due to the fundamental mathematical principle that a low amount of characters has a very small number of options available.

I get where you're coming from but I'm wondering if that's undersells the value-add of link shorteners as literally just shortening the link.

I remember that I liked using link shorteners because they gave me analytics on who clicked my link and where from. I believe paid QR Code link shorteners operate on a similar principle of offering analytics on where and how QR Codes are discovered.

And while in theory, this should be handled by first-party analytics, the users of link shorteners don't necessarily always have control over that analytics platform (e.g., student researchers driving traffic to a survey on an institutional domain).

cowlevel • today at 1:12 AM

The alternative is typing or scanning the actual address.

➕ show 1 reply
dspillett • today at 1:12 AM

> but the alternative is everyone having a short domain

Or just not bother.

Practically no one types a URL like that any more aside from a few biggies like BBC.co.uk, Amazon.com, etc, and even those are usually cached in URL history so they only type the first couple of characters. When were you last given a URL by voice, rather than being given a suggestion to “search for [something-or-other]”? The 140 char limit on Twitter¹ is now 280 making a really short URL less important there, those foolish enough to pay for the site can post much longer missives in one go, and I can't think of another popular site with a stringent artificial post length limit. People looking for your stuff by name will search², not type your address in.

I use a deliberately long name for humour value³. Though I host nothing on there that isn't just for me and friends so this is maybe a special case, I doubt that for many sites a short name makes much real difference these days. People who see my stuff do so by clicking a link, not typing anything in.

--------

[1] the social network desperately trying to be known as “X”

[2] or ask AI which amounts to the same thing usually

[3] subdirectories or subdomains (depeding on my mood at the time) of doubleyoudoubledoubleewe.www.dash.deeohhtee.dash-dash.enneeetee.net

➕ show 1 reply