This comment is where the risk is.
Also, my company at the time saw an uptick in account takeovers when HotMail (a popular free email provider) changed their policy to allowing usernames to be recycled. Because email account ownership is basically equivalent to identity proof for most websites, HotMail's policy change effectively cost us a massive customer service workload. (I think the mass liquidity of virtual items out of accounts was more of the direct issue, not so much that users were still active on our site while being inactive on their email account for a year)