logoalt Hacker News

112233 • yesterday at 6:35 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

I am even less of a professional and this whole field looks exactly like audiophile snake oil peddling. "log" makes total sense because codec cannot encode full precision sensor values (otherwise, just save that!) Any floating point is "log". As long as image carries color space and the mapping LUT, you can convert it into a linear space, which is only thing that makes sense for most operations. Instead, people are taking these "shmony super log8 plus ultra" files, and looking at them directly! they say "log looks flat", they adjust contrast and curves on it, ... How is that making any sense? What "look"? Why is reversing any such LUTs not done automatically? Super weird


Replies

KaiserPro • yesterday at 9:57 AM

log _was_ a compromise. It allowed one to do film scanning at the right level between precision and storage.

cineon, which is where you could argue that log came from, was a 10bit format to represent something that could have easily been 16bit. The compromise was that you kept the precision in the blacks for recovery, but with the ability to actually handle the files on hardware at the time. (bear in mind that realtime 10bit colour playback at 2/4k required a rack full of harddrives up until at least 2010 (see baselight 8 hardware))

I would hope there are 14 and 16 bit formats that come out of the camera that allow you to have some sort of linearish recording. Now that sensors are actually capable of capturing a dynamic range greater than top end film stock. However light isn't linear, so log is actually closer to how we see than linear is.

What ever it is, there are many levels of hidden LUTs to get the camera to record in a way that its meant to. what ever you are doing involves fiddling someone else LUTs

➕ show 1 reply
jiggawatts • yesterday at 7:05 AM

Video formats historically did not include gamut information, made wild assumptions, etc.

So when log formats were introduced, you had to know the color space and undo the mapping semi-manually!

DaVinci Resolve — a colourist tool ffs — just got automatic color space detection a couple of versions ago!

Compared to still image photography where color management is the default, videography is insane.