logoalt Hacker News

renehsz • yesterday at 7:12 AM • 17 replies • view on HN

It seems some people aren't happy about the fact that this course only glosses over each topic, teaching students only superficial knowledge instead of doing a deeper dive on one or a few.

But let's not forget that an overview of what’s even possible is extremely valuable in its own right. When these students are later faced with a problem X, they'll remember that there was this thing called Y which might help. They won't know the details, but at least they'll know where to start looking.

This is especially important if you want to rise to managerial positions, and it might become more relevant now that AI agents are increasingly capable of implementing things: Solving problems is not all about how to do something, but also about knowing what can be done at all. Laypeople often have no idea what's possible, but engineers do, which lets them be creative with their tools.

All of this is not to downplay the value of true in-depth knowledge of a specific subject. But those subject matter experts typically gain their expertise on the job, or at a later stage in their academic life when they conduct proper research. An overview course like this one doesn't hurt even if many students will choose to specialize later on.


Replies

tekacs • yesterday at 7:49 AM

A book recommended to us when applying to Trinity College, Cambridge was 'The New Turing Omnibus' by A.K. Dewdney [1].

It's still to this day one of my favorite reads. By the time I read it, I knew about a lot of the possibilities within it already. But it does exactly this: it skims across the top of dozens of topics, and it makes you just aware enough of... all sorts of areas of CS.

If you're curious, you might dig deeper - at worst, you know these all exist.

[1]: https://www.amazon.com/New-Turing-Omnibus-Turning-Excursions...

➕ show 8 replies
qalmakka • yesterday at 11:11 AM

A gut feeling I've been having since the start of the LLM era is that horizontal knowledge (aka, knowing that stuff exists, can be done in certain way, being able to understand the details without knowing them intimately and being able to do it with a wide array of things) will start getting more and more important the further we go in, because if you know that stuff exist you can point an LLM at it or get it to go in a specific way that it wouldn't take otherwise. LLM have a very strong tendency to just go from point A to point B, and they're often limited to what you can prompt.

This is basically the opposite of the last 50+ years where vertical knowledge (being a savant in a certain very specific field) was seen as the most important thing to have in a super specialised world.

This of course is just my perception, which needless to say, may be wildly off

➕ show 3 replies
pmontra • yesterday at 7:37 AM

I fully agree and I add that this applies to every kind of job. I recently watched a plumber open and clean some pipes. I understood (at least at a superficial level) what he was doing and I've been able to complete the cleaning myself (he couldn't for a number of reasons that don't matter here.) Of course I've been clumsy and I took N times as long as he did but I finally got water again in my kitchen. Without watching him maybe I wouldn't have trusted myself to open some connections or I would have taken hours or days to reason about what was going on and probably do a lot of useless work.

Going back to CS and IT, I found myself talking many times along the years with good software developers coming from a totally different education path (graphics, philosophy, agricultural science, etc) and they had blind spots in areas that I had been exposed to at least a bit at university. Examples: SQL, one of them knew perfectly well how the ORM of the day worked (some JS one 12+ years ago) but not why; networking, one of them knew only to enter the SSID and password and everything else was magic.

xbmcuser • yesterday at 7:42 AM

This is the reason I think LLM are not being used to their full potential. A lot of busy office work can be automated if people knew they could get llm to make them scripts to do it. Where as currently a lot of people keep asking the llm to do things instead of asking the llm to build tools to do stuff.

➕ show 3 replies
CobrastanJorji • yesterday at 8:54 AM

This is why "T-shaped" knowledge is so valuable. You need depth in a given area. You should absolutely be an expert at the thing that you're most immediately doing most of the time. But you should also have a great breadth of knowledge, especially within your field, and the reason is so that you recognize situations where a particular solution to a problem you encounter may be relevant. That gives you the opportunity to learn more about that solution.

lordnacho • yesterday at 7:52 AM

Indeed, this is what university actually IS. You won't be an expert in anything much at all when you graduate, but a broad survey will tell you how experts divide up the field, what concepts matter, and you will have a decent BS detector for your area of study.

➕ show 2 replies
tygon • yesterday at 8:55 PM

Exactly. If something here catches one's eye, one is then invited to keep researching deeper. This kind of "breath then depth" approach is often seen in articles as it is rarely possible to dig as deep as one can on a subject while giving proper attention to other subjects in an article while still keeping it digestible.

Darmani • yesterday at 9:53 AM

> It seems some people aren't happy about the fact that this course only glosses over each topic, teaching students only superficial knowledge instead of doing a deeper dive on one or a few.

Then those people should be very happy to know that this course is the equivalent of multiple full time jobs. "I had 16 hours a week to spend on everything that's not this course" is something I've heard from multiple people who have taken it.

The "overview of what's possible" is instead instead provided by Intro to Making, the "baby" version of this course which I took.

dofm • yesterday at 9:19 AM

Indeed, this is the kind of course that would be useful on any CS degree, because it places the specialism in a wider context.

LarsDu88 • yesterday at 8:01 PM

This is a course? I thought it was a list of links for an LLM to build super weapons?

rq1 • yesterday at 10:45 AM

Yes. An index is always useful.

laidoffamazon • yesterday at 5:38 PM

The reason why it’s superficial is most of the students are already experts at at least one of these topics by the time they take the class, usually even before they attend undergrad at all.

santoshalper • yesterday at 1:08 PM

I don't know if people still use the term, but long ago, this was referred to as a "survey course".

teiferer • yesterday at 12:31 PM

> But those subject matter experts typically gain their expertise on the job,

For some things, mainly practical applied skills, that is the case, but for a whole class of others it is definitely not. Theoretical foundations are one such area. Whatever you do not learn in college you will never pick up in the job. I have may colleagues who were weak on complexity theory or database theory or things like security fundamentals or number theory or even probability theory and they have never managed to bridge that knowledge gap compared to their colleagues who were strong in those things right out of the gate. Make sure to deep dive at uni, that is likely the only chance you get. (No, watching a bunch of youtube clips does not cut it.)

mihaaly • yesterday at 11:30 AM

Even in the ancient ages of no AI long long time ago, the benefit of university education was not in learning specific methods and approaches for specific use but in learning to learn specific methods and approaches for a specific use, including learning what the specific use entails.

baxtr • yesterday at 11:51 AM

In my experience people are disappointed whenever their expectations are not met.

Maybe the course promises more than it delivers. It can still be very valuable.

LoganDark • yesterday at 7:48 AM

I'm struggling to find prose. I just see lists of buzzwords. Am I reading it wrong? I struggle to see how this teaches superficial knowledge.

➕ show 1 reply