logoalt Hacker News

rickdeckard • yesterday at 9:03 AM • 6 replies • view on HN

He's a colorist, stating that many videographers shoot log incorrectly and decide to defer the work to post-production, creating unnecessary complexity and bad source-material.

The plea is for filmmakers to stop following the hype, use what they are experienced with and take ownership of exposure again ("Many times a videographer will shoot log incorrectly – generally underexposed – expecting to ‘fix it in post’").

Because in his experience log doesn't add substantial value, it creates lower-quality base-material with substantial post-production work.

It makes sense. Creative work comes from decisions being taken, log means that the videographer is not deciding but is deferring the task to post-production, creating a unnecessary burden (and possibly diluting his own creativity).


Replies

ZiiS • today at 9:31 AM

The options are: Shoot log badly (extra work in post); shoot Rec. 709 badly (unusable); or shoot either correctly (everyone is happy).

➕ show 1 reply
ajasmin • today at 6:34 AM

Couldn't a camera just show a grade in the viewfinder while still recording in a log format. The viewfinder settings could be saved as metadata, perhaps with some margin so that a "saturated" capture can still be brought back a little in post as needed.

➕ show 3 replies
throw0101d • today at 12:21 PM

> ("Many times a videographer will shoot log incorrectly – generally underexposed – expecting to ‘fix it in post’").

At least in photography, the general rule of thumb is if you're going to err, to at least err to overexposure: you'll still capture some details and you can pull down if needed; if you underexpose it's much harder to fix things.

This goes back to even the film days ("Expose for the shadows…" — Ansel Adams).

➕ show 3 replies
whizzter • yesterday at 9:58 AM

I can kinda see "both sides of it".

Technically, the issue if I'm getting is that the camera physically (or in teh encoding) will be better at capturing within a certain range that you adjusted for, having parts above or below that isn't capture properly and if material is in those above or below ranges the output after grading will not have a good range of values (ie possibly introducing banding).

Underexposing probably feels like a "safe fix" rather than adjusting properly all the time since with more limited ranges it'd be easy to "wash out" with overexposure (irreparably removing things due to clipping), and with budgets cut it's probably easy to just skimp on a lot of these "details" if the system "is capable".

So it's budgets/speed/creativity at shooting time vs material that might just not be good to work with in the end. (Also as he mentions some of these systems aren't as sensitive, probably leaves a situation where some people who's used the better systems just don't realize that it's a problem coming to others).

Edit: Noticed some other comment mentioning that these "log" encodings are 10bits, yeah that's going to leave a bad trail of numeric resolution if you've exposed badly, it'll probably be workable for a huge range but it's not enough by far to recover really badly exposed stuff.

➕ show 1 reply
trueno • today at 10:01 AM

man people were saying this like a decade ago. back when cameras were more limited and log allegedly offered a way to squeeze more out of non-raw footage, i remember people getting mad at the log look and colorists hating working with it.

i tuned out of filmmaking a while ago but it is funny to see people say "stop following the hype don't shoot log" because this was the hype over a decade ago when vimeo was overtaken with dslr/mirrorless "cinematic test videos". i don't know that it's hype as much as it is the internet is filled with amateur filmmakers writing articles and making vids not truly understanding the tools they are working with. if this is a colorist working for actual productions it would be weird to me that a dp might not know these things. feel like a good dp has enough understanding of the colorist pipeline to not just recklessly chuck log footage at them, especially on sets where alexas and reds are rented

ano-ther • today at 7:22 AM

What are good introductions to this? I edit videos from time to time and am puzzled by all the coloring options in Premiere and my cameras.

➕ show 1 reply