logoalt Hacker News

mkrecny • yesterday at 12:37 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

pubs yes - but caffeine vs alcohol is important

the author of the paper avoids giving any weight to two big features:

a) all male spaces (not true of modern cafes) b) almost exclusively white/european

it is pointed out that the coffeehouse is a non-European invention - and some of the original proprietors were non-European - he even examines why coffeehouses in the Arab world didn't produce scientific progress - his answer is that they were suppressed by the powers that be

the British pub is the closest thing we have today - but they increasingly skew old in age - and are too much IMO "places to drink alcohol" "places to watch football" vs what the coffeehouses represented - they are also relatively expensive


Replies

a-saleh • yesterday at 1:06 PM

Teahouse in my university university city is closest I have around me. Many are ... central to various scenes. But that is also due to events-hosting. I.e. when I wanted to learn about cohousing, local anarchists had their caffe. There is a tearoom local larpers and kinksters tended to frequent. Stuff like that.

pj_mukh • yesterday at 7:35 PM

>>" he even examines why coffeehouses in the Arab world didn't produce"

Though the first explosions of intellectual prowess in the Arab world, I think, lines up really well with the first invention of caffeinated drinks from coffee beans imported from the Horn of Africa!

Peteragain • yesterday at 6:38 PM

Yep. We moved to the UK from Oz 20 odd years ago. People ask why, and I say "the beer". The truth is that I can walk into almost any pub and start a conversation about a stupid or tabu topic. I, myself, privately, think Russia has a point re Ukraine and NATO. I have read the history. But to discuss it, the pub is my only option.

➕ show 1 reply