logoalt Hacker News

entropie • yesterday at 5:18 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

My garmin 8 tracks chin ups very well to without any additional hardware. Its like 10% deviation from the total number.

Funnily, my fenix 6 I had before was more like 1% deviation. It tracked chin ups REALLY well.

besides this: its very scary what the 8 is tracking and how good it actually is. I had a covid case this year and the health metrics were all over the place and the warning lights lit, including skin temperature.

This was the first night: https://i.imgur.com/ws1jTv4.jpeg


Replies

sublinear • yesterday at 8:15 PM

On the other hand, the "in range" value in that screenshot was a blood oxygen of 96%?

I'm not saying these devices don't work, but the values displayed are all relative and should be taken with a grain of salt.

Even the best pulse oximeters used in hospital care have this problem. Small blood vessels constrict for any reason from being cold to stress or even just standing up.

The accelerometers are the star of the show, not the other sensors.

I see a lot of these comments namedropping brands and models, but that can be misleading for some potential customers. They all still suck pretty bad in some common and some slightly different ways. I would not even depend on any smart watch or smart ring to tell me if I have sleep apnea.

➕ show 1 reply