logoalt Hacker News

basch • yesterday at 5:38 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

Crazy that a company can use a contract to buy up all the supply to build an inferior product that’s less energy efficient and then sell it at a higher price than the purpose built counterpart. Market failure.


Replies

nostrademons • yesterday at 5:59 PM

They're not really the same markets. NVidia is selling chips that AI runs on, Google is selling services that use AI. Google's play is to make better services than the competition can because they control the full infrastructure stack, thus preventing their markets from being commoditized. NVidia's play is to commoditize the AI providers so that the number of services expands rapidly, with NVidia chips powering all of them. Arguably it's Google's strategy that is the market failure, as it's designed to keep competition out, but...

Google's used this strategy a few times before, and it frequently doesn't work out. They kept MapReduce and GFS proprietary so they could build better big-data services than everyone else, but Doug Cutting from Yahoo clean-roomed it, and then eventually you had interviewees going "MapReduce? That's like Hadoop, right?" They had a long string of internal ML frameworks well before the rest of the industry (I remember in the '00s and early '10s Google was by far the leader in large-scale machine-learning) but had to open-source TensorFlow in the face of external competition, and then lost in the marketplace to PyTorch because TensorFlow was filled with internal WTFs and footguns needed to support specific Google projects. They had a big lead in datacenter technology over everyone else in the industry in the early 2010s, but kept it internal and proprietary until they were forced to sell it as a service by the huge growth of AWS and Azure, then had to play catch-up as a distant 3rd because they lacked the customer relationships and developer mindshare.

➕ show 2 replies
sjs382 • yesterday at 5:53 PM

> Crazy that a company can use a contract to buy up all the supply to build an inferior product that’s less energy efficient and then sell it at a higher price than the purpose built counterpart. Market failure.

They're not buying up "all the supply to build an inferior product". They're buying it up build a different, high-demand product.

bigyabai • yesterday at 5:44 PM

TPUs are a systolic array. It's not comparable to the hardware architecture that backstops CUDA, nor do they serve the same markets.

The writing was on the wall for TSMC ever since the 5nm node; Apple proved that anyone with enough liquid cash could block competitors from fab access.

➕ show 1 reply
joe_the_user • yesterday at 8:38 PM

It's logical that company like TSMC sells capacity to the highest bidder.

The main thing is that chip manufacturing is the most highly capitalized industry in the world. Each manufacturing step has gargantuan costs and so no company wants to manage (and pay for) all the steps - so TSMC buys chip manufacturing equipment from ASML and sets up a system where corporations buy capacity. It's essentially a very, very, very expensive print shop. The print shop doesn't make its own printers nor it print a newspaper.

And naturally, with very, very objects like leading-edge chips, "inferior" or "superior" is a ridiculous simplification. Nvidia chips are incredibly powerful and useful. Nvidia has been more committed than any other company to general purpose GPU programming.

But Nvidia also is doing it's best to sell at high, monopoly prices. That's why they buy a lot of capacity. The thing about the situation is these companies did spend a lot of money reaching this monopoly situation so from their viewpoint, this monopoly pricing might be fair. But I personally wouldn't care and hope some regulation stops it. But that kind of regulation would still have to get these companies significant profit on these investments, so they'd keep making them.