logoalt Hacker News

mlmonkey • yesterday at 6:00 PM • 21 replies • view on HN

The world has plenty of barren, desert areas; do we really need to put solar panels in grass fields? I'm not against it, but just wondering why not just use barren land? Surely it's got to be cheaper than putting them grassland?


Replies

noddingham • yesterday at 6:02 PM

I believe transmission is an issue so having the solar array nearer to where the energy is needed is important. Not that we couldn't spend a lot of effort to figure out better transmission methods but that's one of the reasons why blanketing a desert is not as effective as it seems on the surface.

➕ show 2 replies
saalweachter • yesterday at 7:20 PM

The thing you have to understand is that you like, don't really make any money as a farmer.

It's not about "where can we put solar panels", it's about "how can farmers lose less money farming".

If you can put solar panels on a pasture and not significantly impact the agricultural value, it's another revenue stream which will help you survive the next agricultural crisis that bankrupts the next swath of small farmers (the next one being the one we're currently in, where diesel prices are up and ag prices are down).

chamomeal • yesterday at 6:20 PM

A guy I know works on a sustainability research farm. They basically spend all their time trying out different strategies and technology to figure out how farms can be sustainable without sacrificing productivity. It’s a non profit. They’re well respected in the surrounding farming community, and they get other farmers to adopt new practices.

Anyway there’s my ethos. This farm has solar panels only on top of grazing pastures, cause it keeps cows cool. They’re not like blotting out the sun or anything. It’s a productivity and health boost for the cattle, and renewable energy that runs other systems on the farm.

schiffern • yesterday at 6:15 PM

  >The world has plenty of barren, desert areas
Often (but not always) these areas are actually degraded by human influence.

In these cases, we should regenerate the ecosystems we destroyed, not treat it as "free" surface area that doesn't matter just because we damaged it.

No sane Antique Shop has a "you break it, it's now yours to do whatever you like" policy. I wonder why? :)

➕ show 1 reply
jgilias • yesterday at 6:15 PM

My country has none. It’s all forests and grassland. Plenty of solar farms with sheep grazing on them. I quite enjoy using locally generated electricity as opposed to depending on some other country for our energy needs. We still do that ofc for oil and gas as we don’t have those.

nine_k • yesterday at 10:55 PM

The world has e.g. Sahara, barren areas all over Middle East, parts of Central Asia, etc, within or close to the tropical area, and reasonably close to industrial and post-industrial consumers. These place would be perfect to produce solar energy year round, and have little if any competing uses.

But do you think it's the lacking technology that prevents turning vast areas of Syria, Libya, Iraq, Israel, Yemen, Pakistan, or, say, Congo into colossal solar powerhouses? One can name various reasons, but I'd say that they all boil down to the current lack of wisdom in humanity as a species.

➕ show 1 reply
philipkglass • yesterday at 6:14 PM

Like noddingham said, avoiding long distance transmission is one reason. There is a lot of opposition to new electrical transmission projects, which makes them slow and difficult to construct, even in countries that otherwise support renewable energy (like Germany). In the United States, the SunZia transmission line entered operation this year:

https://patternenergy.com/sunzia-comes-online/

It took 3 years to build from start of construction but 20 years from start of planning:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SunZia_Wind_and_Transmission#H...

MattGrommes • yesterday at 7:59 PM

If they have an ecological benefit, what's the problem? Just looks?

Most of these "grasslands" were formerly a rich ecosystem of different grasses, bushes, trees, etc. We've mowed it all down and converted most of them into monocultures, basically deserts with grass instead of sand. So putting in some shade isn't necessarily degrading these systems, they're already degraded. If the panels provide shade and places for birds and insects to live, it's improving the situation.

jsphweid • yesterday at 6:12 PM

Grazing animals like shade too, like silvopasture. Might as well be something that also benefits humans?

Havoc • yesterday at 6:58 PM

That’s why Europe keeps talking about putting solar on North Africa.

It’s not a bad idea but comes with a number of substantial challenges so hasn’t seen much traction this far

➕ show 2 replies
TulliusCicero • yesterday at 9:56 PM

That's fine for places in or near deserts, but other biomes exist too, often far away from any deserts.

JoeAltmaier • yesterday at 8:50 PM

"Barren land" is a name for the most sensitive arid ecosystems on the planet. Solar farms would upset them drastically. So there's that.

stickfigure • yesterday at 6:15 PM

Dunno where you live, but here in California pretty much every square foot of undeveloped earth is covered with some kind of foliage. Grasses, shrubs, chaparral, forests, etc. Grass is just another ground cover, it grows by itself.

There's nothing really "barren" in a natural landscape. Maybe dry lakebeds?

➕ show 1 reply
undersuit • yesterday at 6:10 PM

Barren land? Where's that? Are you thinking US deserts?

https://www.fws.gov/project/wildlife-friendly-solar-energy

KaiserPro • yesterday at 6:08 PM

grassland tends to be nearer population centres.

iamflimflam1 • yesterday at 6:41 PM

As others have pointed out, transmission. But also accessibility - being able to service these things is important.

sophacles • yesterday at 7:12 PM

Why would it be cheaper? That's not a given.

All sorts of reasons make sense though:

* farmer wants supplemental income - if X fewer sheep means you can have > Xprice_of_sheep dollars from solar. Not to mention diversifying income streams.

Transmission losses are real.

* not everywhere has access to a desert.

* A lot of places are barren "deserts" due to overgrazing, and the overgrazing causes a lack of shade that is a positive feedback on desert conditions. Solar panels can provide just enough shade to bring back plants and grazing area.

einpoklum • yesterday at 9:31 PM

Because we don't all pool all land available to humanity all over the world; very often, a town, a family, a company or even an individual have some plot of land, and it may make sense to use it for solar electricity production rather than purely for agriculture or animal husbandry (or whatever).

aleqs • yesterday at 6:10 PM

Another thing I'm wondering - would putting solar panels in the desert help moisturize/greenify the desert over time because of the extra shade?

➕ show 5 replies
jeffbee • yesterday at 6:02 PM

[flagged]