logoalt Hacker News

Goto80 • yesterday at 8:44 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

If you want high quality results, you need skilled developers who know their business. It's that simple.

I could stop writing at this point because that's all you need to know to understand why "software is breaking down".

Anyway, the problem is just that there were never enough skilled developers while the demand for software was ever growing. That's the reason why the software industry has always been crowded with unskilled amateurs doing grunt work. Amateurs were tolerated simply because of the lack of highly skilled developers: one good developer can easily replace 5 untalented code monkeys, but it's better to have 5 untalented code monkeys than 0 good developers so that at least something gets done. Programming languages like PHP or JavaScript lowered the bar, attracting even more, even less talented people. It really started going downhill during the dotcom bubble, well before cloud computing was a thing, and it never stopped going downhill.

In such an environment, if you want quality results, the amateur work requires supervision and strict quality gateways so that good code can be distilled from the bad. That is, code monkeys must be managed and supervised by more disciplined, more skilled, more talented developers who are actually capable of understanding and managing the complexity of software.

These days, however, everybody is being dumbed down by AI. Everybody even seems to enjoy being dumbed down by AI, even those who actually are (or rather, used to be) good developers. Instead of doing proper code reviews by a professional, an AI is consulted to do the review. Instead of planning a software architecture, people are vibe-coding. Instead of doing a simple change that actually works, an AI is asked to generate spaghetti code (and you don't recognize the spaghetti because you don't understand your architecture anymore). Good practices that served as safety net against low software quality are ignored because "AI doesn't need them".

Of course software is breaking down, now much faster than ever before! It is because we (as an industry) are moving at neck-breaking speed and have stopped thinking, even those few of us whose job is to keep the quality at least at an acceptable level.

Spaghetti Claude is killing quality faster than most can realize, and it shows already. Your amateur code monkey crowd has been replaced by even less talented, but much faster AI with a knack for convincing language. Your code monkey crowd is still there, but it is now instructing the AI to produce results the monkeys don't understand and push to production. Quality gateways have been dumbed down or simply removed to keep up with the speed.

It's a bad development that needs to stop.


Replies

jjk7 • yesterday at 9:41 PM

Good engineers have mentally checked out; some great engineers have already left the industry entirely.