logoalt Hacker News

lukeschlather • yesterday at 8:51 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

The pulse ox does not work. Wrist-based pulse ox sensors cannot work reliably. Heart rate and motion work. On my Fenix 6 I tested the respiration and it doesn't work. Skin temp works, but it's not a very useful metric (unless you're in the water, in which case it very accurately measures water temperature.)

That said their calorie metrics work excellently in my experience. Not perfect, but good enough to be better than anything I could do by hand, and good enough to actually track calorie usage. The calorie metrics use both accelerometer and heart rate as input though.


Replies

muststopmyths • yesterday at 9:46 PM

Sleep pulseox on my fenix 7s is garbage. I assume, because it frequently reported very low values for me while sleeping.

But in the measurement mode where you touch the dial and sit still for a minute, I've found it to be 100% concordant with a finger monitor used at the same time. over multiple reading on multiple days.

This was in a high-altitude environment where I was having trouble, so it's not a case of "both report 99%, so they're in agreement". I think I was down to 90% or some such low number.

anecdata I suppose, but convincing enough for me.

➕ show 1 reply