I assume the long-term business model of a web site catering to freeloaders isn't great.
It wouldn't be a proper Wikipedia article without highlighting an obscure, largely irrelevant quote about neo-Nazis.
Not everything on the web has to (should) be a business.
Wanting to be free from tracking, awful people
It shouldn't matter to much if you have an account on a website to get content and watch ad or not.
You get just more valuable as the product if you have an account.
I'm lost though why you are defending here neo-nazis and pure capitalism shitting over privacy for selling more private data for more money.
"freeloaders" isn't a technical term, care to use one that is and stake a real claim here?
Very few accounts on BugMeNot were ever paid subscriptions. The vast majority (and my exclusive use of it) was to opt out of having to sign up for an endless stream of useless spam just to access something small.
Frankly, if you found your non-paid for site in BugMeNot then the failing is yours. You were gatekeeping some piece of content while providing no other value to users that might inspire them to create an account.