logoalt Hacker News

Brian_K_White • yesterday at 10:38 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

For you to say that means that you can't imagine any reason for thinking or doing something other than that a tribe said to.

In fact, it is possible to do something, like finding someones actions objectionble, and like declining to have dealings with them for that reason, without any tribe having told you to do it.

I don't care how great someone's cakes are, if I also know that person kicks a puppy every day on the way to their bake shop, if I have any choice I will just get some other cake somewhere else or maybe even just live without cake altogether if that is the only source of cake in the world and I can survive without cake. It's perfectly "product-related" because there is no single definition of what is and isn't part of the "product".

I understand HN is overrepresented with people that don't understand that, or claim not to anyway.

I'll tell you, there is no "tribe" telling me what to think about comments like this trying to present terms like "product-related" and "just tribal" as probably their favorite word "rational" they love to use any time they actually just want to be assholes but not suffer the stigma of it.

They always think they are House MD or the witch in Into The Woods: "I'm not good, I'm not bad, I'm just right". Yeah ok, how fascinating and novel. No one has ever tried that before. Certainly not every single douchebag teenager in the world since the beginning of time. Certainly we don't have an entire word right in the dictionary just for the concept of attempting to present a refutable biased position as an irrefutable unbiased one by selectively presenting some facts and connecting reasoning that appears rational on it's own, namely "rationalization".


Replies

apparent • yesterday at 10:46 PM

You seem to have misread my comment. I didn't say anything about a tribe telling anyone to do anything.