logoalt Hacker News

tempestn • yesterday at 11:27 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

What are the fundamental differences between data center and crypto workloads that makes it work for the latter but not the former? I guess the former would need better network infrastructure, for one thing. But both seem like they should be fairly similar on the CAPEX vs OPEX front, no?

I'm also not sure the associated gas from oil wells is actually that intermittent? I think at least in some cases it can produce power pretty consistently. Just not forever.


Replies

hinkley • yesterday at 11:46 PM

There are different kinds of stranded power. A gas flare has, I presume, an expected average rate of production per day and if that is either stable or you provide a reservoir, you can install enough hardware to consume the median output, and then cross your fingers it will be depreciated before the well is exhausted. Not knowing much about wells (mostly only as pertains to GG emissions), I can't say if that's likely or virtually guaranteed, but I think we can deduce it's at least very likely, since it's already being attempted.

Then there's stranded solar and wind, and hydro, where either the grid cannot use the current power, or the transmission lines aren't rated to handle peak power. Those would all idle your equipment quite often, particularly in the case of peak shaving. Or conversely, if there's a power station you want to run as base load and keep running even when demand sags, and so you get a discount based on the cost difference between the producer's other options.

Perhaps some day we will have a thermal battery that is sufficient to vary the power draw of a datacenter by banking or expelling heat on a cost/benefit basis, but the heat pumps are only a fraction of the total power draw, so getting more than a 25% discount on net power draw seems unlikely, and then subtract travel time for maintenance and administration, theft prevention, etc, probably doesn't work out.