I disagree, because I think the default should be no access, then manually checking those folders and whether there may be something in them that you don't want the app to access. How many git repos contain secrets, that you may want to exclude? If you get a popup saying an app wants access to an entire branch of your filesystem, it shouldn't be easy to approve that with a single click, without granularly checking what's in there beforehand.
Many apps already work this way and request access to a single directory, and the best apps (little snitch, arq) give you fine control over what is accessible for what actions.