logoalt Hacker News

collabs • today at 8:03 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

The position is internally consistent. Most apps should never touch the file system outside of their own folder structure that they control.

You can export files to an external location and you can import from external locations in this scheme but they will be user directed.

With this scheme, you would teach most users to select NO!!! if any app asks for full disk access or system access.


Replies

DaiPlusPlus • today at 6:30 PM

With this scheme you’ll increase IT support’s blood pressure for most computer workflows in business (unless they do everything through a point-and-click web-browser, in which case why use a desktop computer OS at all?)

“My Photoshop plug-in doesn’t work”

“My Outlook macro that creates emails for each PDF in this folder doesn’t work”

“There;s a readme.txt in Matlab’s .app folder, but TextEdit says it doesn’t have permission to read other program’s private data files”

“The only way to back-up our files now, without scary warnings, is to pay Adobe/Apple $lots/mo for each app’s own silo iCloud-based backup service”