logoalt Hacker News

dvdkon • today at 9:07 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

All the apps you listed probably work the same on your Mac as they do on an iPhone. If that's the kind of software you're using, then it makes sense you're happy with macOS' current permissions.

MacOS is also used by power users, though. The kind of people who were drawn to it being a user-friendly UNIX and then stayed. I think it's reasonable for them to ask for a more granular permission system that actually supports their usecases.


Replies

smilespray • today at 9:14 AM

Sure, and power users can grant access.

Regular users need a way of giving informed consent.

The existing system reminds me of Windows; poorly dialogs designed without any thought for regular users whatsoever, which causes everybody to grant access to everything, as a knee jerk response.

➕ show 1 reply