logoalt Hacker News

zkmon • today at 11:07 AM • 3 replies • view on HN

> To the extent that taxpayers donate to their hometowns, Tokyo no longer freerides on the substantial public expenditures required to raise and educate internal migrants.

This is really great idea and justice too.

For decades, the countryside in every country have sent off their youngsters to work for the country's economy. The real unsung heros are the rural families who spend everything on their children education and well being, only to be separated from their loved ones. It's not just families that got impacted; the entire communities, villages and districts became devoid of young work force who prefer to move to cities.

This was tolerated under the assumption that the cities provide better living conditions for the youngsters and the next generations. But cities survive in an ecosystem provided by the country side. Starve country side, you starve cities.


Replies

servo_sausage • today at 11:38 AM

Nonsense, people aren't "sent" they leave because the rural areas are fundamentally obsolete, they offer very limited lives, and produce very little.

They offer no reason to stay.

Their government takes money from a productive area to subsidize a rural one, in a feelgood program to purchase the votes of the non productive at the cost of a higher tax burden elsewhere.

From the city's perspective the countryside is an incredibly expensive way to provide some quantity of raw material, not some wellspring of labour since the 19th century.

➕ show 1 reply
carlosjobim • today at 12:08 PM

What's the justice? To me it seems that hometowns didn't give young people the opportunities they should and drove them away. And on top of that they now want to lay their hands on the juicy, juicy money that they didn't earn.

> their youngsters

No, everybody is their own person and deserves to keep what they worked hard to earn.

lotsofpulp • today at 11:42 AM

Was it tolerated, or did automation and more efficient transportation make most rural people’s labor unnecessary, hence necessitating they move for work?