logoalt Hacker News

cloudbonsai • today at 11:14 AM • 8 replies • view on HN

This is a way weirder system than the name suggests. patio11 explains it in detail in the article, but the gist is:

1. You can contribute to rural areas in return for a tax credit, effectively allowing you to redirect a portion of your taxes to another town.

2. The most important quirk of the system is that you can choose any towns to contribute to. There is no requirement of previous residence or whatever. In fact, most people contribute to towns with which they have no personal connection.

3. This ended up causing tax competition among local governments. Quite a few towns started advertising expensive "gifts" to contributers ("Give us your taxes and we'll send you some goodies"). It went so far that some towns got banned from the hometwon tax system.

It was introduced with good intension, but resulted in a very inefficient tax system.


Replies

tokioyoyo • today at 11:55 AM

Me, and quite a few people I know, have visited different towns that we would never go to just because of this. I’m not sure how it affects the towns in a national scale, but it’s weirdly fun.

shioyama • today at 12:46 PM

"weird" is putting it lightly. patio11 paints over most of the issues. This is not a good system, and it absolutely does not solve the stated goal of distributing money back to the regions.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50530561

lopis • today at 1:29 PM

To me it seems like the main issue is that donations are not anonymous. The author explains that, for cultural reasons, in Japan gifts should be counter-gifted in ~30%, and that somehow explains this convoluted system. But these aren't gifts - they are taxes! There's no reason why towns should know the name and address of the people who transferred their taxes to them - they should receive the tax money in bulk. But of course now it's almost impossible to change this system because no town will agree to changing it.

sandworm101 • today at 11:39 AM

I wonder about secondary effects. There seems to be the possibility of "Disneyland economies", a main street fed up by cash from people who with no connection and who do not draw any local services. I could see this propping up towns with better marketing teams, or towns who cling to whatever esthetic most pleases their outsider benefactors. In the extreme, would local people lose political/financial power in favor of the outsider tax base?

➕ show 1 reply
cucumber3732842 • today at 11:39 AM

The US should adopt that for state and local taxes. Donate to another state, get a write off in your own. Would create a nice incentive to not be hated by your own populace.

Of course, the architecture of the US government more or less precludes it, but it's fun to think about which states and cities would go instantly bankrupt.

➕ show 2 replies
ragall • today at 5:16 PM

> It was introduced with good intension, but resulted in a very inefficient tax system.

There's no requirement for the tax system to be "efficient".

fendy3002 • today at 11:58 AM

> Give us your taxes and we'll send you some goodies

this doesn't count as corruption? if it does, it will solve itself

➕ show 2 replies
igleria • today at 11:34 AM

how inefficient? At the very least I do find the idea entertaining!