It does not have to be perfect. And really, it cannot be. There will always be corner cases. If it works in most cases, I am happy to enable full access for apps that really need it. I am not going to do it for 100 apps, and I am not going to do it if the app fits one of the cases where it does work, either.
As a developer, it’s another set of hoops to jump through. As a user, I am happy that there are some guardrails (that I can disable).