logoalt Hacker News

vezycash • today at 2:12 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

Everyone in the US knew phones were destroying attention spans years ago, but educational bodies and school boards punted the burden down to individual schools, teachers, and parents. Of course it failed: no single teacher or parent wants to be the bad guy and face social friction.

China just banned them outright. It's the same with companies - weak committee vs. a founder who just makes the hard call.


Replies

japhyr • today at 2:22 PM

Absolutely. I was a high school teacher in the 2010s, and it was such a hard aspect of teaching to navigate.

For any reasonable phone policy to be implemented well, it has to come from the highest level of administration. It has to be enforced consistently across all levels from the district/principals down to individual classroom teachers. That requires a lot of people to understand the issue well, come to agreement, and be capable of enforcing difficult policies.

There are so many factors that make it difficult for this to happen. Parents who disagree with policies, often for valid reasons. Staff turnover makes consistency difficult. If one teacher lets students use phones, it makes it harder for everyone around them to manage the policy effectively. If groups of teachers don't adhere, it gets even harder.

This is no different than the impact of AirBnB on housing availability, especially in tourist destination towns. Tech companies create a situation that's really hard to manage, and then leave it to individuals and small organizations to manage something that really needs to be figured out at a societal level.

tootie • today at 2:48 PM

It's really not obvious and genuinely feels like moral panic to me. The data here are so weak for something that is supposedly so harmful. It doesn't stand up to scrutiny. I don't think phone bans are worth the cost of the pouches. In some small ways it's actually hurting kids. They used to take pictures of the board or check google classroom assignments and now they can't. Mine are more likely to miss assignments now than before the ban and I don't see any change whatsoever in kids behavior.

➕ show 3 replies
flawn • today at 2:20 PM

Some others would say it's the same as with liberal or totalitarian states - you are to judge what you do vs. a unchecked despot.

But I agree, this is long overdue and capitalism has figured out how to defacto undermine individual judgement to a level that we need some railguards.

sneak • today at 2:39 PM

> Everyone in the US knew phones were destroying attention spans years ago

I think that is the general consensus but I think that is only so because of common knowledge; I do not actually believe it is true, nor do we have any data to indicate that it is the phones any more than it is the continuously declining curricula in the US. Correlation is not causation.