logoalt Hacker News

PennRobotics • today at 2:23 PM • 0 replies • view on HN

Think about the Zoom F3 recorder (prosumer equipment) as quasi-Log.

The F3 has dual preamps: one low-gain and one-high gain. For quiet passages, you can really pick up a lot of detail with a low noise floor. For loud audio, the low-gain preamp takes over to avoid clipping (although the noise floor abruptly raises, so very subtle sounds previously audible to the high-gain preamp would be lost). Both preamps have a bit less dynamic range on their own compared to a professional recorder, but by having two gain stages, it can approximate the same dynamic range as, say, a Sound Devices recorder.

I don't know for sure, but I'd expect (due to the nature of the ADC chips in the F3) that if you slowly increase the amplitude of a reference sine wave from -120 to +28 dBu, you'd see a lot of small increments in the waveform peaks while the high-gain preamp is active and then large increments until audio starts to clip at +24 dBu.

-----

The audio post-production professional's equivalent of this log rant would be, "Stop sending 32-bit floating point 192 kHz audio to post! Serious individuals only send unprocessed 24-bit WAV-format ISO tracks, at 48 kHz or---with prior approval in specific video settings--- 48.048 kHz."