logoalt Hacker News

cnczeric • today at 3:08 PM • 0 replies • view on HN

What struck me is how the gift mechanism quietly changes the question the system answers. The original idea was about where tax money should go, but once towns compete on gifts, the decision becomes which town offers the best return, and the towns that need money most are not necessarily the ones best at marketing. Several commenters living in Japan make that point from opposite directions: some enjoy discovering new towns through the gifts, others say small towns bleeding young people still lose out. That split suggests the design flaw is not the redirection itself, but letting the reward be a private good instead of a public one — if the 'gift' had to be a local project, as one commenter mentions, the competition might actually serve the towns rather than the donors.