The tools are good, but the ideas are not. These tools basically see many people building the same things independently, rapidly, and over and over again.
I'm not seeing a lot of unique applications. I am seeing some optimization, plenty of rehashing the same crap. Lots of thought outsourcing.
Honestly, I'm mixed as someone who also uses these tools. Is it really efficient for 100s of people to be spending tokens and electricity to all make, effectively, the same bad app from their shower thought/idea? I love that we've democratized coding so that it's more accessible to laypeople - but it is mostly all slop and lack of creativity being produced. And, in the rare instances where someone genuinely makes something good, 100x people will then spin their own AI to rip off the same idea.
Where does this all go at the end of the day for humanity when nothing is new or creative and we are going backwards in critical thinking along the journey? Especially since the journey IS the thing for humanity - not the end product of the journey.
Whether great or not, it seems to follow the birth of home videos with youtube, tiktok, etc. The video industry went:
- from highly founded centralized creations (TV, movies, series),
- to highly founded centralized creations (TV, movies, series) plus public home made videos (influencers, etc.) plus private home made videos (vlog for friends, etc.).
I can imagine the same with software, where big highly funded software remain, on top of home made software. Some home made software on neglected areas might be exchanged on some social platform (for example, apps to help women track their period was neglected for a long time), and some will just be for friends and family (like a personalized educative video game with a kid's favorite plush).
This is why I feel like any AI usage is making us all crabs in a bucket when it comes to progressing as a society. Any genuine creativity or effort is immediately stolen and repackaged as someone else's, which inherently means that its incredibly difficult for the original author to get any credit and devalues any genuine progress. And most importantly, people are doing this to deny the author any profit
We seem to be in a situation where 0.1% of people are creating anything new in the programming space, which isn't a change at all, but the difference now is that there's an absolute army of people waiting in the wings for the second they finish to take credit - and profit off their work without compensation. Because apparently that's progress, according to some people
This has been happening the most in realtime with news sites, where any news they publish is fed into chatgpt and recycled to avoid giving them any clicks or advertising money. What happens when all the news sites die because chatgpt ate their ability to survive? We'll go backwards as a society because we won't have news, and then suddenly chatgpt will lose its ability to report the news. Lose lose, unless you're an extreme short termist
It extends to everything with AI, its giving us negative progress as a society, because its society eating itself in exchange for the shortest time line go up
Original ideas are not "allowed" in a sense that the infrastructure will fight or directly forbid you. Your original ideas will have hard time to go through Apple AppStore's review or Gooogle's Android or Chrome processing. You will have hard time getting paid for it, you will have hard time to make people hear about it because x, FB, TikTok, reddit etc all have an agenda and they don't spread things that don't fit it(AKA medium is the message).
We don't live in a free world where you can just do things anymore, you are supposed to fit the machinery that is churning hundreds of billions of dollars every year.
The problem is that the tool and the marketing around it make people think they can circumvent the time it takes to refine ideas into a good experience or product.
You cannot, in the end, eliminate time. There are no shortcuts. It's like Euclid said, there's no "royal road" to mathematics, nor to a good product.
LLMs can speed up several aspects of execution, but actually honing an idea, figuring out what constraints make sense, how the experience needs to be tweaked, in brief, design, will always take time. The one shot revolutionary product notion is total myth.
I'm honestly massively disappointed.
I expected tools when animator can just put a bunch of keyframes, sketch the transitions and have AI fill it in, getting all of the artistic vision with massive work saved.
Instead industry went full on dystopia "let's replace entire jobs" instead of settling on just massive efficiency improvements on top of keeping the quality and we got million slop generators and little of the actual good tooling that would change the industry, outside of coding tools.
I blame the subsidies and free AI. Can't blame people for building dumb things when it's so cheap and disconnected from the actual costs. That demand then manufactures shortages that wouldn't otherwise exist... The public gets swamped with slop which they view as all AI can make, so they hate the technology. It's the worst of all worlds.
This really isn't limited to software. A more egregious example is music: we already had every genre, every mood, at our fingerprints practically for free. And now, we're just giving a big middle finger to human artists for no benefit whatsoever. Well, except that Spotify might be able to pay $0.0000 per stream instead of $0.0001.
On some level, I understand where the individual impulse is coming from - "I couldn't do this and now I can, it's amazing" - and I can understand why amoral VCs would throw money at these platforms. But I will never understand why so many intelligent, sensible people are cheering for this future.
Look at all the new book releases on Amazon. They are 95%+ slop, and not good slop. They're made with zero effort. Some of them sell because people judge books by the title & cover. What does this achieve? Once you eliminate all revenue for real authors, what next?
> I'm not seeing a lot of unique applications. I am seeing some optimization, plenty of rehashing the same crap. Lots of thought outsourcing.
Nihil novi sub sole but at AI scale.
> many people building the same things independently, rapidly, and over and over again.
It's the Lisp curse, magnified by a million.
Or maybe the tools are not good?
I can't write more than a few prompts without the LLM (any of the latest SOTA models) starts doing complete absolute nonsense.
I do agree that the ideas are not good to be clear, but the gap between the promises of what LLMs can do and what they can actually do is huge.
Anyway, it's funny to see the insane amount of astroturfing on HackerNews and how people try at all cost to make it seem like the technology isn't the problem but humans actually are. Literally every top-level comment is about that, or downvoted.
> I'm not seeing a lot of unique applications. I am seeing some optimization, plenty of rehashing the same crap.
Democratizing coding via LLMs is democratizing cooking via frozen foods. It's gonna be unhealthy to the end user despite the convenience. And the taste level will not be there. Sure, you "made" dinner just like you "made" an app.
> The tools are good, but the ideas are not. These tools basically see many people building the same things independently, rapidly, and over and over again.
Isn't this just every bubble technology since the 80s? I remember being at parties in the early 2010s and hearing awful web site ideas that were certainly feasible with an RoR stack but had a <1% survival rate. The only difference now is less engineers acting as gatekeepers.
I'm certain it was the same way with static HTML webstores in the 90s, social media since early blogs, and other industries that received funding spikes that eliminated financial barriers (construction, film, video games, restaurant chains, etc)
Eventually the Gartner Hype Cycle proves true and the hysteria dies down, but out of those promised elevators of progress come a few incremental steps upward.