logoalt Hacker News

smallmancontrov • today at 3:47 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

Everyone makes crayon scribbles as a child. What does this achieve?

Everyone learns the same basic curriculum in school. What does this achieve?

Everyone makes mediocre attempts to play instruments/sports as an adolescent. What does this achieve?

Everyone treads the same highs and lows of friendship and romance that have been tread by billions of others. What does this achieve?

It achieves the human experience. Not everything has to be best-in-class to be meaningful, and that's a dreadful expectation to heap upon anything that doesn't strictly demand it.


Replies

JDups • today at 4:15 PM

"Passive income" grifters spamming amazon with books that they literally spent 0 time or creative effort on are not "achieving the human experience". There is no creative/personal satisfaction or development from this, it's just people making things worse for others trying to make a quick buck.

tavavex • today at 4:10 PM

The things you listed are considered to be smaller version of 'proper' expression in art or mastery of some skills that humans value. Even if most people go nowhere with some of them, they're still seen as commendable things to do and parts of the universal experience.

What is AI generation a smaller version of? While you can make worse and better AI outputs, do you think the average Kindle slop author is going to one day become a proper bestselling writer? Will an average Suno music generator turn into a musician?

techpression • today at 4:02 PM

Difference being people did those things compared to a prompt, there’s no experience to be had from prompting “make music” in relation to trying to play an instrument or lay out a track.

➕ show 1 reply
fodkodrasz • today at 4:04 PM

What does having machines do stuff instead of Everyone making that stuff on a not-best-in-class level achieve? What is the Human Experience in that?

Apart from more wealth inequality and environmental pollution, of course, which is what we call The American Dream nowadays.