logoalt Hacker News

smallmancontrov • today at 4:28 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Playing someone else's music doesn't teach you how to compose. Laying out a track in fruityloops doesn't teach you how to play the instruments.

Complaining about negative space is easy but not very informative because the attention doesn't go missing, it gets reallocated to something that someone found more engaging. I remember the vitriol aimed at DAWs 25 years ago, but it was obvious then and correct in hindsight that what was lost in forced mediocre specialization would be more than made up for in expanded capacity, and that anyone who wanted would still be able to drill down and master an instrument, but that they would now be in a position to determine where this would be most impactful. It's the same fight all over again.


Replies

darkwater • today at 4:42 PM

Unpopular (and unrequested) opinion: I still think that the world's best DJ mixing music live on stage in a club is not the same class of job as an amateur pop band playing in a pub in front of family & friends. The latter being much more meaningful.

➕ show 1 reply
techpression • today at 4:58 PM

Learning how to compose and play are two different skills though, they are likely to reinforce each other, whereas a prompt is just something completely disconnected. It wasn’t that long ago people were thinking prompt engineering would be a profession of the future, and now you barely need to be able to spell to get the same output.