Given the Hacker News bias towards tech, it is easy to focus on just the challenges of exploiting AI for software development.
The problem is, to justify the substantial investment in data centers and the eye-watering valuations of Anthropic and OpenAI, AI has to successfully reach into essentially every niche of the economy. It can't just be a tool to code faster. It must make most jobs faster period. From daycare to farming, we need relatively short-term ways of integrating this technology.
AI will survive the hype cycle, but the AI companies very well may end up like railroad companies or Iridium, where the shareholders got zeroed out and then someone comes in, buys the assets for 10 cents on the dollar, and builds something useful out of it.
It is going to require new companies that organize themselves around AI. Existing companies have too much inertia to adapt. Sears was selling virtually anything through the mail 100 years before Amazon. But it required a new company in Amazon to truly take advantage of the Internet. The same will be true with AI.
My hot take is that the tech is already there to make most jobs more efficient. Not 10x, but 1.2x-5x depending on the field.
The actual barrier to integration, which just isn't going to happen. If you haven't been in deeply established companies (think old chemical companies), you really don't understand the resistance to actually implementing even simple changes to workflows and tools.
It took nearly a year and a half to automate a workflow moving data between an internal system and SAP. Entirely because the responsible party "didn't understand why we needed it". It represented >50% of her time, we eliminated the manual work entirely. Actual implementation is going to be fighting weaponized incompetence at every step.
> The problem is, to justify the substantial investment in data centers and the eye-watering valuations of Anthropic and OpenAI, AI has to successfully reach into essentially every niche of the economy.
No, it just has to “optimize” knowledge work, since knowledge workers “cost” enterprises about $50 - 70 trillion a year globally. Even a 10% “optimization” is about a $5T value.
But of course we know they expect a lot more “optimization” to happen, after all Anthropic thinks their TAM is $30T.