logoalt Hacker News

Someone1234 • today at 6:20 PM • 5 replies • view on HN

My big hope for this release is - Have they got their massive over-engineering under control?

Say what you will about Opus 5.5, but it has a good "gut instinct" for how large/complex to design the solution. The previous Astra just absolutely loved pointless abstractions, excessive numbers of files, and just over-complicating very simple things within an inch of their life.

And, yes, you can prompt your way out of anything. But needing a default prompt to tell OAIs models to work better isn't preferable, particularly when that sometimes gets lost in sub-agents and the over-engineering returns into parts of the work.


Replies

scandinavian • today at 6:31 PM

I've been using both sol and astra to write some python and rust, and they generate the sloppiest code I've seen in a long time. I would be embarrassed to commit anything they write. The rust code especially was terrible. Had it implement a reader/writer for a binary format and it was just littered with magic numbers, terribly named variables, very compact code visually etc. It produces working code, so I guess the GPT models are mostly for people who let AI take the wheel 100%.

holzhaker1 • today at 6:27 PM

yeah i feel like with astra they went all in on 3D modelling which encourages "just one tweak, just one more tweak" which makes it detailed enough, but in coding that same behaviour just sucks.

uw_rob • today at 6:31 PM

Honestly I don't even know if you can prompt your way out of these types of behaviors - stylistic tics and judgement seem to be extremely difficult for the models to overcome. It seems we are tied to what the labs do unless we want to dive into and get dirty with models yourself. In retrospect with time it becomes obvious that the previous generation of models couldn't be prompt engineered to do what the current generation of models do. There's just no way you will prompt engineer Opus 4.8 to write as well as Opus 5.5. I'm guessing with time we'll see that there was no way you could prompt engineer Sol 5.1 to be as token efficient as Sol 5.2

➕ show 1 reply
incrudible • today at 6:45 PM

I have limited experience with OpenAI models, but I have to say that Opus 5.5 has not improved on the terrible writing style, and I am struggling to prompt my way out of it. It always needs an extra pass dedicated just to rewrite all the prose.

➕ show 1 reply
pants2 • today at 6:35 PM

Lol I made the mistake of having Astra design and build a complex system without any input (experimentally). Seemed functional at first and shipped it internally and it had dozens of complex bugs, so I started digging into the architecture and it was a monstrosity! Definitely 10X more complex than it needed to be.