logoalt Hacker News

whh • today at 1:30 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

There's a serious disconnect between us who build and operate the internet, and those who legislate it. Courts seem to believe anything is technically possible, and that their jurisdiction extends to the architecture of a global network.

This French ruling doesn't stop piracy. It will drive reputable providers out, undermine privacy and push users towards less transparent alternatives...

The irony? The judge might go home and use an ISP that collects and potentially monetises their DNS. That's their choice. But why should everyone else lose the freedom to choose a privacy-respecting alternative?

We can't expect every judge to become a network engineer. But we should expect them to understand the consequences of their decisions.

The internet routes around this nonsense. Unfortunately, everydayy users pay the price.


Replies

cowlevel • today at 12:16 PM

If something is technically impossible, then it won't happen. But since the last N things courts ordered did happen, they conclude that they are technically possible, and those who say they are technically impossible are lying.