logoalt Hacker News

_heimdall • today at 2:26 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

Isn't this a Biden era policy? Trump sucks in many ways, but inept government spans both parties and isn't limited to recent history.


Replies

tacticalturtle • today at 2:41 AM

And ironically the push for universal login.gov is coming from the Trump administration:

https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/M-26-1...

➕ show 1 reply
antonvs • today at 10:28 AM

The 2020 Trump administration made the decision and pre-funded the program, i.e. established a blanket purchasing agreement for the services. This essentially started a ball rolling that would have taken effort to reverse.

More detailed timeline:

In January 2020, under the Trump administration, the IRS determined that login.gov didn't meet its identity verification requirements.

In August 2020, still under Trump, the Treasury Department established a blanket purchasing agreement with ID.me. The IRS began ordering services under that agreement in June 2021, during the Biden administration, but the decision and funding had been established under Trump.

The ID.me procurement was done 17 months later, under the Biden administration, using the existing Trump-era purchasing agreement.

By February 2022, still under Biden, there had been criticism of the face recognition requirement, and the IRS announced that it would work towards adopting login.gov.

Login.gov achieved independent certification against the relevant NIST standard in October 2024. Trump took office three months later, and the transition never happened. It's unlikely to be prioritized under the Trump administration.

> inept government spans both parties

This is not ineptness so much as an ideological preference for using private companies to provide public services. This is often heavily influenced by well-funded lobbying.

For example, the 2005 proposal by Rick Santorum, to restrict public access to restrict access public to weather information that's available from commercial weather providers, was heavily lobbied for and funded by Accuweather. Happily, that one didn't become law.

Some that did become law, backed primarily by Republicans, include municipal broadband restrictions and the 2003 legislation for Medicare Part D which favored private insurers over federal price negotiation.

This Pew Research report shows that among supporters of the two parties, there's a strong preference (74%) among Democrats for government-provided services, with Republicans preferring commercial services by comparable margins:

https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2024/06/24/americans-vi...

Whether that translates to actual policy is subject to all the usual vicissitudes of the political process.