The issue with paying money for something like this is that retaining the line - i.e. your ability to prove your identity and merely function in the economy/society - becomes dependent on this payment being made and received on time, successfully. Should anything get in the way of that, your digital life becomes at risk. That is not a great tradeoff.
With a free service, retaining the line becomes dependent on the provider continuing to offer this free service, and their whims in deciding whether to continue providing it to you. There's no free lunch.
Doesn't that describe 99% of SMS plans people use for 2FA?
If I stop being able to pay $5 USD a month from any Visa or Mastercard or future standard American payment system (and they will notify me if it declines), I have bigger problems in my life than my 2FA.