> login.gov, on the other hand, didn't offer any alternatives
Untrue unless something has changed recently. That one actually seems reasonable to me. You can create an account in your browser and then verify it in person at your local post office.
I did have trouble with login.gov being broken by my blacklisting of sketchy third party domains. An official government website should _never_ require loading resources from any domain that resides under a commercial tld. If our legislators were even halfway competent they would completely ban such practices. Call it the REAL Network Security act or something.
The verification options depend on the site you’re signing into. Some are willing to pay for the in-person verification service; others, like the IRS, are not.
I have this issue with the California DMV website. I basically have to disable every measure to use it without it silently failing at some step.