logoalt Hacker News

toomuchtodo • today at 4:31 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

ID.me could meet IRS remote identity proofing requirements Login.gov could not at the time. Higher identity assurance is required due to historical rampant refund fraud, fraud that has cost billions of dollars.

> The government’s in-house digital identity service has not been without its share of controversy. A March 2023 GSA Inspector General report found that agency officials had misled customer agencies by claiming Login.gov met identity assurance level two standards set by NIST when it actually did not. GSA promised later that year to add facial recognition capabilities in order to meet that standard.

https://www.nextgov.com/digital-government/2026/08/white-hou...

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49312680

https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/leader-sophisticated...

https://www.justice.gov/archives/tax/stolen-identity-refund-...


Replies

fc417fc802 • today at 4:44 AM

That's just a fig leaf to cover up vested interests. You can get a refund without ever presenting any ID if you submit the traditional paper forms by mail. So the IRS could have verified newly created online account by mail if they so chose. Or they could even have had you main in a paper form to create an online account. Instead we got ID.me and poor excuses for why login.gov was insufficient.

➕ show 1 reply
FireBeyond • today at 4:31 PM

ID.me is/was such a farce when I signed up:

"Scan the front and back of your Driver's License."

[upload scan of front of DL @ 200DPI]

"Unable to find a face in the image you uploaded."

[upload scan of front of DL @ 300DPI]

"Unable to find a face in the image you uploaded."

Huh. Maybe I'll try with a lower resolution.

[upload scan of front of DL @ 72DPI]

"Thank you, now please upload the back of your Driver's License."

Hmm, 72DPI worked for the front, so...

[upload scan of back of DL @ 72DPI]

"Unable to read a barcode in the image you uploaded."

[upload scan of back of DL @ 200DPI]

"Unable to read a barcode in the image you uploaded."

[upload scan of back of DL @ 300DPI]

"Thank you for verifying your Driver's License".