logoalt Hacker News

fc417fc802 • today at 4:52 AM • 3 replies • view on HN

That doesn't seem to be a coherent response to what I wrote above. I pointed out that you can today claim your refund via paper forms without ever presenting any ID. So it is inconsistent that I cannot also register via mail the online account for doing same.

The reports are the proverbial fig leaf to which I refer. What happened with ID.me is a textbook example of grift.


Replies

RobGR • today at 3:00 PM

If you fill out a paper 1040 form for your 2025 taxes, and you don't put a bank account and routing number to receive the refund, their online documentation says that you must create an account on irs.gov to provide that info and they will no longer send paper checks. In fact for at least one person who could not do those things, they eventually sent a paper check. But there is no form to claim your refund if you have already filed the 1040 form.

duskdozer • today at 8:00 AM

IIRC you used to be able to get creds to access your IRS returns by some physical mail process a few years ago. They started preventing access from those accounts though to force ID.me.

toomuchtodo • today at 4:54 AM

> The reports are the proverbial fig leaf to which I refer. What happened with ID.me is a textbook example of grift.

Believe what you want, it was a unilateral decision by a Login.gov representative out of equity concerns that had to be remediated with technology implementation per the Inspector General’s findings. Provide evidence ID.me was a grift, conversely. Without evidence, it’s a grift solely because you believe it is, and not based on any evidence. They were a commercial vendor who could meet the NIST standards required (800-63-3 Digital Identity Guidelines https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/63/3/upd2/final), and Login.gov could not because of a willful decision to deceive partner agencies about the capability.

> Our evaluation found GSA misled their customer agencies when GSA failed to communicate Login.gov’s known noncompliance with the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Special Publication (SP) 800-63-3, Digital Identity Guidelines. Notwithstanding GSA officials’ assertions that Login.gov met SP 800-63-3 Identity Assurance Level 2 (IAL2) requirements, Login.gov has never included a physical or biometric comparison for its customer agencies. Further, GSA continued to mislead customer agencies even after GSA suspended efforts to meet SP 800-63-3. GSA knowingly billed IAL2 customer agencies over $10 million for services, including alleged IAL2 services that did not meet IAL2 standards. Furthermore, GSA used misleading language to secure additional funds for Login.gov. Finally, GSA lacked adequate controls over the Login.gov program and allowed it to operate under a hands-off culture. We found that because of its failure to exercise management oversight and internal controls over Login.gov, FAS shares responsibility for the misrepresentations to GSA’s customers.

If you want your nation state identity provider to be taken seriously, it must operate seriously, which it was not doing, based on the IG investigation. It was the grift until adults were installed.

➕ show 1 reply