Looking at HN itself, the user choice for accessing paywalled information is looking for some "archive" site to skip it.
Many years of race to the bottom turned significant number of new sites into husks that strait up just republish everything from AP, only using AI to rephrase that source.
And lastly, just like it happened with streaming services, introducing paywalls doesn't mean all crap associated with ad-founded content will magically disappear (low quality, clickbait), and ads themselves will be back on site, to double dip.
Looking at HN itself, the user choice for accessing paywalled information is looking for some "archive" site to skip it. Many years of race to the bottom turned significant number of new sites into husks that strait up just republish everything from AP, only using AI to rephrase that source. And lastly, just like it happened with streaming services, introducing paywalls doesn't mean all crap associated with ad-founded content will magically disappear (low quality, clickbait), and ads themselves will be back on site, to double dip.