logoalt Hacker News

UqWBcuFx6NV4r • today at 9:30 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

No, it’s because it’s a valid and useful fraud signal. It’s just one that has downsides that you personally do not like / are affected by. No model is perfect but some are useful. I assure you that this one is. It’s not for me to say whether or not it’s OK for governments (or the quasi-government entities that a government forces its people to interact with) to use signals that have this particular sort of false positive profile, but you’re being baselessly conspiratorial.


Replies

soulofmischief • today at 9:39 AM

Lots of things are "fraud signals" which are actually just intentional class boundaries.

Your government can use Signal to organize bombings in Yemen, but if you use Signal, you're a potential terrorist.

Sure, a phone plan can be a fraud signal, and that fraud signal will be used as part of a modern digital redlining campaign, denying or restricting access to American citizens who either were born into poverty, value their privacy against the State, or both. It doesn't matter if fraudsters actually fit the profile, but the State appreciates hiding behind the plausible deniability of statistics.