logoalt Hacker News

nicbou • today at 10:29 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

I slightly disagree here. Many of the things on the website come from interviews with experts, or from collecting data directly.[0] This information was not on the internet. Hell, even immigration experts are often confused about things. We have a group chat where we help each other out. I had to create that community.

I created that website in direct response to all the incorrect information on Reddit and in Facebook groups. In the absence of official information, you are bound to find a lot of rumours. I used to be pretty active on the /r/berlin subreddit and boy oh boy were they wrong about a lot of things.

When I travel, I have a similar experience with more obscure border crossings. The information about them is generally incorrect, and you end up with a dozen websites parroting the same incorrect source. Curation involves checking the information.

[0] https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/immigration-office/wait-ti...


Replies

brainwad • today at 12:16 PM

The AIO gives more or less the same answer as you for the permit question, without ever citing you[1]. They instead cite ESCP, ServicePortal Berlin, Expats in Wonderland, Proforg, r/berlin, the Aussies in Germany FB group and Visaguard. Your data collection effort is cool and impressive, and makes it easy to recommend your site as a one-stop-shop for new expats; but to answer the question, you are sufficient but not at all necessary.

It is interesting to think about whether we will lose some key sources of information if AIs snipe all the easy queries that can be answered from multiple sources, leaving not enough traffic for the people who were generating the data to live off (because they were cross-subsidising the hard work with traffic to their easily reproducible work). I guess one option is more paywalling for the stuff that requires hard work (i.e. the way news/blogs went, and also the way this used to work, when people would buy a book to guide them on a move to a new city).

[1] https://imgur.com/a/ETyhjE8

EDIT: just noticed the Reddit post cited is actually you! I can see the rationale for citing Reddit/HN comment threads over the page itself, but it also feels a bit like citation-washing.

➕ show 2 replies