> The solution, the sole way to slow it down, is to strictly isolate the major global networks. I should note that's the sole way to do it in reality (insert comments: yeah but if we just follow fantasyland ideals we'd do xyz and everything would be 197% secure).
IMO, strict isolation is slightly more fantasyland than, say, having the AI make it all secure.
So, while you're:
> I'm not talking about Google's network.
I think even they would struggle.
For:
> I'm talking about the other 99% of the economy that is wide open, built up on a garbage pile of poor practices in terms of security, focused on dealing with slow moving human threats, not millions of superhuman threats.
I agree this group will handle it catastrophically badly, but I aver it will remain so if the attempt is "strictly isolate".
When I was doing my degree, it was reported that "12345" and "password" were among the top 10 passwords; if that kind of pattern is no longer the most common password, it is only because enough people banned it.
One story around the same time said you could get most people's passwords simply by asking for them. Another, that you could easily get onto a secure network by leaving a pen drive in the company's car park because someone would likely pick it up and plug it in - indeed, even supposedly air-gapped systems (e.g. the Iranian centrifuges) get hacked because people plug in things they're not meant to plug in.
Normal people are not paranoid enough for this. I am not paranoid enough for this despite being aware of it when I actually think about it. The NSA wasn't paranoid enough for this when Snowden did his thing, and human nature being what it is I'd be surprised if they became sufficiently paranoid even after that.
> They'll be screaming in the halls of Congress for network isolation as a solution (to preserve their own businesses and reputations): they'll say if we just reduce the potential sources, if we reduce the easy access from outside, we can focus on securing our own USAnet (USAnet, EUnet, Runet, Chinanet, etc).
Could be. As a non-American, this will be quite funny if this happens, given the economic impact inherent to the US from no longer being able to sell Big Tech to the rest of the world.
None of this will be a choice made by experts. This will not be a decision made from a standpoint of what is the most rational way to set up everything.
The decisions will be made by politicians. It will be made on the basis of power, control, fear, ignorance, public outrage, etc. It will be made in a moment of intense public uproar. They will not trust AI systems to secure the economy against other AI systems, that approach will take over a decade to deploy fully anyway, we don't have that kind of time. As the attacks rapidly increase, the politicians will reach for a hammer solution in desperation, and that one solution is intensive network isolation.
The politician will say: why are we allowing foreign actors access to our networks to harm us with AI? The answer is: there's no reason to allow it, it is not necessary. Note that China has done just fine with its network isolation, its economy has not languished for it, they will be viewed as proof that it can work well.
Big tech won't be prevented from selling to the rest of the world. They'll follow local laws/rules just as they have to right now. They'll help other nations build their own isolated networks (smaller nations will federate with other nations on this), and they'll offer services within those networks. Canada for example would be very likely to federate with the USAnet and EUnet.