The vast majority of HN has always been pro-ad blocking, arguing that the user's wishes (to see no ads) override the content creator's interests (getting compensated for their work). The HN consensus is also generally, but less strongly, in favor of the primacy of the user-agent over the site in all other ways.
But AI summaries are pretty much indistinguishable from that. The search engine is the user-agent in this case. The user's actual desire is to get the information, and their agent (the search engine) is providing them an easier way to do it. The only differences are that it's on-by-default for 90% of the users rather than opt-in at 25% market share, and that there's no pro-forma page fetch of the content that could in principle be rejected by the site.
And let's be clear: users clearly do want AI overviews / AI mode. We might not understand why the users want it, but Google would not be implementing it if they didn't have to. There's a lot of reasons for why the status quo would have been preferrable, while the only real reason for a change is that the status quo was not tenable and they would have lost share to the sites giving users what they wanted.
The situation is a lose-lose, but it was also the logical outcome of saying that the end-user's wishes have total primacy over the other stakeholders.
AI summaries are very well distinguishable from an ad-blocked browser in the sense you still had to click through.
And second difference, you still had to see the information the way the author decided to present them to you.
This website has also been against copyright since forever. Call them what they are: hypocrites.
It's also the logical outcome of a very hostile, any-abuse-is-acceptable web. People are happy with the AI overview because their experience going through to actual links is often an incredibly negative experience.
Dickovers, teasers, paywalls, cookie banners for 976 partners, auto playing video at full volume, a hijacked browser history, and on and on...oh and now the fact that they looked at that content is going to follow them to Facebook, LinkedIn, and so on.
And if you deal with all of that, often it was SEO-maxxed content that had human bots scalp from other sites. Sites that didn't invest in the "get to the top of the front page" SEO spamming and who made the actual content that just got stolen never got the love in the first place, in many cases.
On Apple mobile devices, forced to use the Safari browser whether reskinned or not, the internet is an especially hostile place. On my iPhone I basically don't go to URLs I don't know, despite having weak ad blockers in place.
The web we accepted as normal basically set the stage for this. Users are conditioned to wince at following a link. We made our bed by allowing this to become the norm.
> The vast majority of HN has always been pro-ad blocking, arguing that the user's wishes (to see no ads) override the content creator's interests (getting compensated for their work). The HN consensus is also generally, but less strongly, in favor of the primacy of the user-agent over the site in all other ways.
I'd argue that the vast majority of HN has always been against tracking, and against obtrusive ads. Ad blocking is only necessary because the former and latter seem to be the only way of doing ads.
> And let's be clear: users clearly do want AI overviews / AI mode. > We might not understand why the users want it, but Google would not be implementing it if they didn't have to.
Couldn't it be that Google thinks it can make more money in the long run by putting themselves even more between the user and websites with AI summaries? It could also be that they want to project their AI to new users, and that the summaries are effectively ads for using Gemini.
I personally don't believe that AI summaries are what users truly want. At least for me: I despise them for how often they are wrong or disregard the context, and how often they seem to take information of copycat Q/A websites.
Websites with the level of quality like All About Berlin were rare before AI, but I think Google will also shoot itself in the foot if it doesn't compensate its sources properly, as quality sources like this will cease to exist.