It's very true. I am hesitant to post things I think are novel now because I know it will just go into training data, unattributed. I even comment on HN a lot less. It's wholesale ripping off of people's IP - the chilling effects of this will not be felt for a while.
Whether it goes into training data is irrelevant. The AI agent (whether embedded into google's search or otherwise) will do the search on behalf of the person, find the answer in your page and return the answer, rather than your page. It's the ability of AI to search and summarize that has changed things. Not whether the LLM itself has absorbed your particular information. Once LLM's were good enough to make reasonable tools calls to search the web it was game over. It's just like how calling a library to ask a factual question of a librarian, rather than having to locate the information in a primary (or secondary) source yourself disintermediated the encylopedia publishers. It's just that calling librarians was never particular efficient or practical.
The internet was dying long before generative AI. You can find posts on Reddit from 2014 of people complaining about how the internet has shrunk to just a few dozen sites.
Copyright is only useful for rent-seeking if you have a popular enough IP and lawyers on speed dial to collect that rent or for censoring the availability of IP. DNS blocks are a type of copyright censorship.
Copyright has little or no value for small blokes and bloketts like us. I think that part of the problem with copyright is that we are blending rent-seeking with acknowledgement of one's contribution in the creation of IP.
I dare say, most of the value of “copyright” for us small players is that it is part of the discovery process through which people with jobs and money find us. My writings and code have led customers to me (in a good way).
I don't mind what the LLM hovers up of my so-called creative efforts as long as people can find me. And that perspective is, I think, the core complaint people have about Google's AI searches. At least, that's how I read the article.
Jeez, I didn't even think of providing free training data. I've been more worried about data harvesting and attributions to some sort of marketing profile (or worse).
So much for "Information wants to be free" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_wants_to_be_free .
While I can certainly concede that the issue is nuanced, I am not really convinced of the negative case.
Firstly I think that if you've decided to stop posting to the Internet because you know an AI will train on what you posted, you're in a tiny, albeit loud minority.
Secondly, LLMs have created competition in the search market which no one else was able to do. A number of reports point to ChatGPT-initiated search volume now having surpassed Bing, maybe by a lot. Combined with other LLMs there is some sense in which Google's monopoly on web search may actually be collapsing. It's about time! When I simply ask ChatGPT to search the web for me, I feel like the results are usually much better than Google.
Third, a lot of the people who are complaining about a decline in Google traffic appear to be invested in some business model or another that I don't think needs to survive. We see traffic statistics for websites in a variety of lines of business. The SEO arbitrage businesses are the ones that are hardest hit. Various of ad-laden, spammy content businesses are hard hit. Real businesses that sell real value, it's a mix, but none that I've seen stats for have been killed off. Nor even have really good content businesses. People bring up how bad this is for media and journalism, frankly I remember what journalism was like before the media was consolidated under a few corporate monopolists, and what passes for the press right now I think deserves to die. And certainly if Fandom is getting less pageviews because an AI is regurgitating Simpsons quotes, fuck them, fuck that site.
I don't doubt that some good sites or businesses will be lost due to changing technology and that's unfortunate. I also know that OpenAI, Anthropic et al.'s DNA is just as evil as Google's. As the craftiest incarnation of Mammon yet, if unrestrained by competition, they will enshittify our lives in record time. But on balance, just not convinced that this is a change for the worse, vs. just a change. ChatGPT does cite and link extensively when you tell it to go search for stuff. The answers you get from its training data tend to suck, and don't compete with answers it generates via RAG and good sources, which it will cite with links. It won't shock me if referrals from AI search end up being rarer but higher quality than referrals from conventional web search.
>It's wholesale ripping off of people's IP - the chilling effects of this will not be felt for a while.
The wholesale ripping off started in the late 90's and we are already deep into the "feeling it". DRM, standalone apps for everything, consolidated corporate internet with paywalls all over.
I'm sorry, I just cannot take anyone on the internet who bemoans IP laws seriously. We all ad block everything and pirate stuff as needed, this is the moral high ground of the internet for 25+ years. Hell LLMs are the worst pirates anyway because they won't even let you just cleanly download the IP you want to steal.
It's completely wrecked the internet for me.
Between SEO spam as the precursor then AI generated SEO spam and then just AI.
I used to enjoy stumbling on random things and learning/seeing into a world I didn't know existed (usually related to tech/science/history) but the signal/noise has changed radically and not in favour of the signal.