logoalt Hacker News

otabdeveloper4 • today at 1:07 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

> while ironically providing Millennium level Lean proofs

They're doing that by generating a metric shitload of schizo syllogism junk that is then sifted through Lean to find a valid nugget. (Or not.)

The implication is that "Millennium level" is mostly stuff that's too tedius for meatsack humans to sift through.


Replies

topicalSoup • today at 6:30 PM

You are factually incorrect about this. If you look at how these proofs are actually being generated, the proof comes first and is only later Lean-verified. For example, take Yang-Mills: it was proved by OpenAI on Sept 9 and then Lean-formalized on Oct 16. If all the AI was doing was sifting Lean, we would expect the proof completion and the Lean verification to happen simultaneously.

zbentley • today at 4:50 PM

I think that’s valuable, potentially. The bitter lesson writ large, basically: lots of problem spaces that previously required reasoning to narrow down possible paths to solutions can now be permitted over much more broadly instead.

Sucks for the project of human learning though.