logoalt Hacker News

kypro • today at 1:11 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

What's the steel man argument for giving all of humanity access to advanced bio research and capabilities?

I think I'm naive sometimes when it comes to trade-offs between freedom and security, but even I'm confused at why it would be a good thing for the whole of humanity having access to this stuff...

My only argument in favour is that it seems rather certain that at some point someone will leak the weights of a model with these capabilities so it might be safer if we brought forward the risks while they are still management so people take them extremely seriously.

If we go 5-10 years and then the weights of an ultra-capable model is leaked that may be game over.


Replies

wavemode • today at 4:03 PM

> What's the steel man argument for giving all of humanity access to advanced bio research and capabilities?

Well that question is very loaded and slippery-slope-ish. To bring things down to practical terms, the real question is "should we pass laws restricting open models". (And probably with an added caveat "in the US", since lawmakers can't control what AI researchers overseas do.) Which has a lot more substance for debate on both sides.

wry_xy • today at 4:51 PM

The knowledge and capabilities are latent regardless of which humans if any have access to them. Same for their risks.

We can "protect" ourselves by limiting who has access, but:

- how often do those "trustworthy" elites use their abilities for abuse?

- it might leak

- someone else could independently obtain the capabilities

- an "act of god" might hit us without human intent

In any event, we're less prepared, because we assumed it couldn't happen. And it's not just bio.

And that's ignoring deeper questions of enforcement or censorship or surveillance.

I won't fight for a world where people are intentionally kept dumb, where the powerful are intentionally kept powerful, and where we intentionally keep ourselves vulnerable.

troupo • today at 1:19 PM

> What's the steel man argument for giving all of humanity access to advanced bio research and capabilities?

What's the steelman argument for giving this research to Anthropic? Or any research that they are now gating?

> My only argument in favour is that it seems rather certain that at some point someone will leak the weights of a model

Yes. Because most of this research is either public, or should be public (but hidden behind bullshit fees by gatekeepers like Elsevier)