logoalt Hacker News

dsr_ • today at 1:44 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Every measurable proxy for your actual goal that becomes a target will be gamed, and thus becomes useless.

In the real world, housing in cities should be more expensive than in the surrounding suburbs, which should be more expensive than the rural areas, because the higher-paying jobs in those denser areas should compensate for that. In return, city dwellers should get a higher quality, availability and affordability of services because they are more efficient to provide in the denser areas.

This doesn't actually happen, because housing policy and tax policy are broken in most areas.


Replies

afavour • today at 2:49 PM

In that ideal scenario, where do the lower paid workers who work in the city live? e.g. is a Starbucks barista commuting into the city for 45 minutes? Those workers are required for the higher-paying folks to enjoy their life in the city so making _all_ city housing expensive could be counter productive.

➕ show 1 reply
wat10000 • today at 3:06 PM

The relative desirability of cities would push housing prices up. But the efficiency of cities should push prices down. It's not clear to me which one should be more significant. Cities do seem to be more expensive in reality, but how much of that is desirability beating efficiency, and how much is artificial supply constraints?