logoalt Hacker News

Energy drinks linked to 11 times more reports of cardiac arrest

175 points • by wjSgoWPm5bWAhXB • today at 2:03 PM • 165 comments • view on HN

Comments

buredoranna • today at 4:40 PM

I remember a great story [1] of a New York Times reporter, spending time in Baghdad, and had developed an arrhythmia.

He went from doctor to doctor, without a solution. Then finally he got to a doctor who asked the right question...

  `There wasn't a lot to eat, which is good for me because I need to lose the weight.'

  `What were you drinking?'

  and I said, `Well, I'm not a drinker, a couple of vodkas
  now and then and that's about it. So I was drinking tea.'

  `How much tea?' he said, and I said, `Oh, 25 or 30 cups a day.'
[1] https://freshairarchive.org/segments/new-york-times-iraq-cor...

(edit: formatting)

➕ show 3 replies
jimmar • today at 2:34 PM

> reports of possible adverse events submitted to an FDA safety database from 2017 through 2025. > Of these, 854 reports involved energy drinks or dietary supplements containing caffeine or other stimulants.

So the FDA gets about 100 reports per year for adverse events with caffeine OR other stimulants. This doesn't feel like a big problem, especially when tens of millions of people consume these products.

➕ show 5 replies
DiskoHexyl • today at 3:40 PM

People who drink massive amounts of energy drinks may be exercising or doing other physically and mentally demanding things while sleep deprived, pre-exhausted/overtrained and/or going past failure. Sometimes with a hangover. At least from a personal experience.

I’m not a fan of energy drinks, but this needs more data

➕ show 7 replies
VolCoder • today at 6:40 PM

I had to drop all caffeine for medical reasons. Let me tell you, withdrawal is real. But honestly now I don't even miss it. I sleep better at night, which makes me not need caffeine in the morning. The feedback loop works both ways.

tancop • today at 5:37 PM

Every drug comes with tradeoffs. Alcohol can give you liver disease and help you talk more openly, smoking gives you lung cancer and helps with stress, weed can make you chill or schizophrenic and opioids can make you feel amazing or stop your breathing.

We all know caffeine can give you heart problems. If you take it anyway that's on you, and sometimes it's objectively a good choice (if you can't work without it). It's called making an informed decision.

I'm not saying life works exactly like a video game but with drugs it's pretty accurate.

➕ show 3 replies
erelong • today at 3:04 PM

"energy drinks" is kind of vague, there's a wide spectrum of drinks available (some are derived from green tea which otherwise is thought to be beneficial; on the other hand lots probably have an excess of sugar which may not be necessary to consume at all)

probably not a problem in moderation

understandable if problems arise with kids having too many or too many than their body can handle (if they have existing health issues they may not know about)

caffeine in moderation has been though to be good for you or people often do not think of it as having a pronounced negative effect, anyway

the hearts of youth could also be being poisoned by something which makes them more susceptible to heart damage from energy drinks as well (like there are supposedly less nutrients in food today from many years ago)

➕ show 2 replies
vova_hn2 • today at 5:29 PM

> Certain energy drinks provide up to three times as much caffeine per fluid ounce as brewed coffee

That's a weird comparison. I think it would be more reasonable to compare one standard portion of each. For example, one shot of espresso vs 1 can of an energy drink.

➕ show 1 reply
vondur • today at 6:10 PM

I had a student assistant who would chug down like 4 of them per day. That can't be good for anyone. Ton's of sugar in the one he was drinking too.

JohnMakin • today at 4:34 PM

It astounds me that people drink things like Celsius, which have 200+ mg of caffeine a serving, and then go do something like work out. Daily maximum recommended caffeine is 400mg, but I know people that have 4 or 5 of these things a day. I have heart problems, so I could never, but I still cannot imagine.

alentred • today at 3:17 PM

Correlation does not imply causality. The study focused on the consumer reports of the adverse effects of various products. It is reasonable to assume that in some (most?) of the cases people consume the energy drinks in the context of another pre-existing condition: maybe they slept less, or are overexercising for example, which can provide an alternative explanation for the adverse effects. This is well admitted in the study too, as they state that more research is necessary.

➕ show 1 reply
t1234s • today at 3:33 PM

Some of the larger cans are not single serving according to the nutritional label. Downing one of these could cause issues in some people.

rramon • today at 4:13 PM

Could it be because of the artificial sweeteners?

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11225337/

➕ show 1 reply
etatester • today at 5:31 PM

What still surprises me is caffeine is mostly unregulated. It's a drug and a lot of drinks just don't list the amount of caffeine they include. Or theine for that matter.

bob1029 • today at 4:41 PM

The added sugar and artificial sweeteners are the actual danger here.

It is rare for a contemporary energy drink to have more caffeine than a cup of coffee. The focus on the stimulants is a red herring.

➕ show 1 reply
adolph • today at 6:21 PM

The cited work [0] is a data mining abstract. The sciencedaily article has a larger wordcount.

  We analyzed the FDA CFSAN Adverse Event Reporting System (CAERS), which captures reports on these products but has not been comprehensively analyzed for cardiovascular signals.
0. https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/abs/10.1161/circ.154.suppl_1...
baggachipz • today at 4:08 PM

I'm more interested in the increased levels of kidney stones in those who consume lots of these drinks.

sandworm101 • today at 3:14 PM

In a military context we are dealing with this on an almost daily basis. We call it "over gaming". A case of red bulls and console games and a totally healthy just-passed-basic-training kid gets whisked off to the hospital at 6am with heart palpitations. They are always fine within 24h, but I only say that because in the military context they are also all younger/healthier than the general population.

With GTA, we anticipate a rush of such incidents over the next few weeks.

[Funny story: I was going to visit one of these kids a couple hours after he arrived at the hospital. He asked me to bring his SteamDeck. NO! I brough him a book.]

➕ show 3 replies
krn1p4n1c • today at 3:38 PM

How much of this is caffeine vs excessive amounts of B6?

➕ show 2 replies
tengbretson • today at 3:28 PM

> Energy drinks linked to 11 times more reports of cardiac arrest

Maybe being cranked on taurine simply makes someone more likely to get a report filed.

➕ show 2 replies
dmtroyer • today at 4:39 PM

what is sciencedaily.com? why not just link to the original article that this is regurgitating

https://newsroom.heart.org/news/energy-drinks-stimulant-prod...

suzzer99 • today at 4:32 PM

I'd like to see the Venn diagram intersection of dudes who pound energy drinks and Zyn all day, but are terrified of MRNA vaccines. I imagine it's large.

Caloric3002Swed • today at 4:26 PM

Now link it with obesity.

Caffeine is an appetite supressant so not sure how everyone is so fat. Tough this past year everyone been losing weight at work. Im down to 18.5 BMI. Feels good man.

➕ show 3 replies
PunchTornado • today at 5:16 PM

So coffee is bad too? How much coffee is too much?

➕ show 1 reply
Madmallard • today at 4:40 PM

Stuff that's bad for you is linked with bad outcomes. No surprise there.

It's just sad and unfortunate that millions of people don't have a choice really. Work two jobs just to survive. Maybe they already had children as well. Or birth control failed and they had children. They're way too tired, so the only way they won't lose their job is to have stimulants. Or painkillers for people who have injuries and aren't able to be helped by disability or other things like that.

Just sad. Hate that the world is fundamentally adversarial even between people.

wonderwonder • today at 3:48 PM

I would have to see more data to agree or disagree but anecdotally, my 12 year old's friends are pounding these things. Drinking 2 or 3 Monster energy drinks a day. 160 mg of Caffeine per can vs 90 in a cup of coffee. No idea why their parents are good with this

➕ show 2 replies
acosmism • today at 3:20 PM

some people should avoid stimulants like caffeine and don't so they have issues. am i reading this wrong?

➕ show 1 reply
nativespecies • today at 3:18 PM

“ Researchers emphasized that the findings do not establish that energy drinks or stimulant supplements caused these medical emergencies.”

barrenko • today at 3:58 PM

It fucks up your gut bacteria as well.

➕ show 1 reply
metalman • today at 2:25 PM

red bull 11x, it's bigger than 10x, see right there on the label, it goes to 11

squidmaster • today at 5:21 PM

[dead]

strangescript • today at 3:30 PM

Its almost like someone who regularly consumes energy drinks might not be super healthy to begin with, then a small amount of them actually have heart attacks

AngryData • today at 2:48 PM

Wow, who could have guessed that stimulate usage can make a bad heart work harder and fail? Oh wait, everybody already knew that.

➕ show 1 reply
covid-vax2 • today at 5:09 PM

[flagged]

➕ show 1 reply
covid-vax • today at 4:03 PM

[flagged]

➕ show 1 reply