logoalt Hacker News

Bender • today at 2:06 PM • 0 replies • view on HN

This is probably an unpopular take, but DNS-level censorship is likely going to have to get worse before it gets better. Right now, forcing resolvers to block piracy or copyright-infringing domains is politically costless. Lawmakers face zero personal friction from breaking the underlying architecture of the internet for these use cases, so there is no incentive for them to stop.

That calculus only changes if the mechanism creates shared pain ... specifically, if politicians themselves get caught in the crossfire. If foreign jurisdictions begin ordering DNS blocks on European political figures' domains for violating local speech or defamation laws, and providers simply comply to avoid legal liability, the precedent suddenly becomes a problem for the people writing the laws.

On a more practical note, I wonder how thoroughly the legal surface area here has been mapped out. Has anyone pointed frontier models at the French legal code to exhaustively search for compliance loopholes or jurisdictional edge cases?