logoalt Hacker News

earthnail • today at 3:10 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Well, as for gun manufacturers: most countries heavily limit how guns can be sold.


Replies

palata • today at 4:14 PM

But they don't blame the gun manufacturers or resellers when someone uses them for crime, even though they "facilitated crime", do they?

And most countries don't heavily limit how hammers can be sold. But they could: we could enforce that when someone buys a hammer, we ask an AI to do a background check and say if they should be allowed to own a hammer, right? But would it be better than nothing? I assume you will agree that it's not so sure.

Ok, not for a hammer. What about a car? We could enforce that everyone is tracked when driving, and then feed that to an AI that would guess how likely we are to eventually cause an accident. Then we could prevent those "potentially dangerous drivers" from having a car at all. Would that be better than nothing? Not so clear.

The truth is that the world is complicated. And often there aren't perfect solutions to real problems.

Security is typical of a complicated problem that fundamentally requires tradeoffs. The thing is, security is also control/power. And it adds up: there are many, many individual cases where we would say "well it may (or may not) improve security, but the cost is a little bit of freedom, so we may as well pay it, it's better than nothing and it doesn't hurt". Except that if you systematically give up freedom for an unclear security benefit, what you do is that you move the balance towards more control/power (and therefore less freedom).