This is satire, right? Do you genuinely believe that a meaningful answer to a question like "best bar" can be derived from wiretapping every public space? That "most popular" is close enough to what people actually mean when they ask that question that the loss of everything else will be accepted?
No.
Yes.
To your third, I think you misunderstood. I am not saying that “most popular” will be used as a proxy for “best”. I am saying that by having enough sensors distributed through society that we are able to tell what people think the “best” bars are to a high degree of accuracy and usefulness.
Also I want to be clear that I am not desiring this. It just seems clear that this is the machine we are building. This is why google feels comfortable cannibalizing search traffic.