logoalt Hacker News

Grombobulous • today at 3:46 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

I love all these hypotheticals that are just detached from real life.

We can preach technical justifications all day long, but Quad9 lost in civil court against another company that brought their grievance to a court.

They were determined to be at fault in civil court. They're either in the wrong or they need better lawyers.

From the perspective of the plaintiff, Quad9 is actively harming them, and the court agreed.

The fiber company might be more culpable or whatever, but they weren't the defendants brought to court by the plaintiffs.


Replies

croon • today at 4:06 PM

Exactly, because it isn't about culpability, but convenience.

> They were determined to be at fault in civil court.

It's generally called "no-fault injunctive relief" because they are, literally, not at fault.

If your jurisdiction can't follow the road sign and shut down the illegal activity where it occurs, we shouldn't move to remove the road signs, we should either rewrite laws such that the illegal activity is easier to crack down on, or as a society accept that money shouldn't equal right in a court of (civil) law.